Private Cloud vs. Public Cloud: How to Choose
In the era of digital transformation, cloud computing has emerged as a cornerstone technology, revolutionizing how businesses operate and manage data. This article aims to dissect the intricate world of cloud environments, particularly focusing on the decision between private and public cloud computing. Understanding these choices is crucial for organizations as they determine which model, or combination of the two, aligns best with their business strategy, security needs, and finances.
Definition and Overview of Cloud Computing
Cloud computing is a transformative technology that offers computing services including servers, storage, databases, networking, software, analytics, and intelligence over the internet, commonly known as "the cloud." This technology is celebrated for its unparalleled efficiency, scalable resources, and potential for significant cost savings.
Importance of Choosing the Right Cloud Deployment
Selecting an appropriate cloud deployment model is a critical decision that impacts various aspects of an organization, including operational costs, data security, compliance, and scalability. The choice of the cloud environment shapes how a business interacts with its digital assets and can significantly influence its market competitiveness.
Private Cloud
A private cloud is a cloud computing environment dedicated solely to one organization. This may include dedicated physical resources, or may be managed as a Virtual Private Cloud (VPC) - where a managed service provider (MSP) will leverage virtualization technology to create dedicated virtual networks for multiple tenants on shared physical infrastructure. Private clouds minimize or eliminate resource contention by limiting access to one or relatively few tenants (when managed by a third party MSP) compared to hyper-scaler; They may be self-managed and hosted on-premises or in a colocation facility, or hosted by a third-party MSP. This model is used when leveraging owned hardware or leveraging services provided by a Colocation provider or existing MSP. Most features and capabilities are limited to those provided by the underlying virtualization platform (e.g. VMWare, Hyper-V).
Public Cloud
Public cloud refers to hyper-scale cloud computing services provided over the internet by third-party providers to multiple organizations or the general public. Well-known examples include Amazon Web Services (AWS), Microsoft Azure, and Google Cloud Platform (GCP). Public clouds are lauded for their scalability, value-added Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS) capabilities, and ease of management. Although the general model is massive multi-tenancy on mass-scale, shared infrastructure, most major cloud providers offer dedicated hardware service offerings to eliminate concerns over resource contention. Public Cloud infrastructure is hosted in data center locations across the world, managed in regions to support multiple availability zones for robust Disaster Recovery and Edge Computing capabilities.
Skip Reading.
Ask the Experts.
Talk with Cavan Group
Core Differences: Private vs. Public Cloud at a Glance
Ownership and Infrastructure:
Private Cloud
May be operated on owned infrastructure and managed by the organization itself in on-premises or colocation data centers. The infrastructure is dedicated solely to the organization, providing exclusive access and control.
May also be operated and maintained by a Managed Service Provider either on-premises or in a third-party hosting facility. If hosted by the MSP, this will typically be operated on in a shared, multi-tenant virtualized environment. This model takes advantage of the MSP’s skilled technology resources for support and maintenance of the virtual environment.
Public Cloud
Owned by cloud service providers like AWS, Azure, or Google Cloud. All hardware and operational software will be managed and maintained by the cloud provider, with a self-service user interface for customers to provision and build out their cloud environment(s). Typically, users share the hyper-scale infrastructure with other users and organizations, leading to a multi-tenant environment, however dedicated hardware offerings are available.
Cost Implications and Investment:
Private Cloud generally requires upfront capital expenditure (CapEx) for hardware, software, and infrastructure. Operational expenses (OpEx) include ongoing maintenance, upgrades, and IT staffing and/or Managed Services expenses.
Public Cloud operates exclusively on an OpEx model with minimal upfront costs. Pricing is typically based on a pay-per-use model, making it scalable and cost-effective for fluctuating needs - when governed and managed appropriately.
Scalability and Resource Management:
Private Cloud
Scalability can be limited by in-house capacities. Expanding resources may involve purchasing additional hardware.
Public Cloud
Offers virtually unlimited scalability. Resources can be quickly scaled up or down based on demand, without the need for physical hardware changes.
Customization and Control:
Private Cloud, in a self-managed model, enables high levels of customization allowing organizations to tailor the environment to specific business needs and requirements. When operated by an MSP, capabilities will be limited to the offerings made available by the MSP.
Public Cloud offers various services and configurations both throughInfrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS) along with packaged PaaS offerings, all highly customizable.
Security and Compliance:
Private Cloud, when self-managed, the organization is fully responsible for implementing and managing security measures. When leveraging a MSP, security and compliance follows a shared responsibility model similar to the Public Cloud.
Public Cloud provides robust security capabilities but operates under a shared responsibility model where users are responsible for securing their data and applications but have no control of the security from the hypervisor down to the hardware.
Maintenance and Technical Expertise
Private Cloud infrastructure is typically built on top of a common virtualization platform and will rely heavily on the functionality and capabilities of the hypervisor. Self-managed private clouds will require hypervisor-specific skills within the IT team for management, maintenance, and troubleshooting. MSP’s will typically provide a service-request (incident) interface for organizations who need to make changes to the managed private cloud environment.
Public Cloud maintenance, updates, and infrastructure management are a shared responsibility between the Public Cloud provider and the Consumer. Organizations leveraging public cloud environments require deep knowledge of the Public Cloud Provider’s capabilities, user-interface, and/or APIs to build and manage a secure, networked environment for the organization’s business needs. Governance and monitoring are critical to ensure costs do not spiral out of control.
Performance and Reliability
Private Cloud: Managed private clouds will typically offer a minimum of N+1 hardware redundancy and alternate site, disaster recovery capabilities leveraging hypervisor-based replication technologies. Self-managed private clouds will require additional capital expenditures to provide hardware redundancy and disaster recovery.
Public Cloud: Provides a wide range of performance and reliability capabilities through mass-scale deployments and configurable as options through their user interface. However, organizations must design their cloud deployments to take advantage of Public Cloud provider’s redundancy, availability zones and disaster recovery.
Data Sovereignty and Legal Considerations
Private Cloud: Data is stored within the organization’s controlled environment or within a MSP’s hosting environment, which can be crucial for legal and compliance reasons
Public Cloud: Data is stored in the provider’s data centers, possibly replicated in multiple locations, which requires special consideration be made for data sovereignty and compliance requirements.
Integration and Modernization
Private Cloud: Integration with legacy systems hosted with the Private Cloud environment can be smoother due to network access and proximity. Modernizing IT infrastructure can be challenging depending on the age and amount of hardware involved and requires additional capital investment in hardware.
Public Cloud: Hardware refresh and modernization is the responsibility of the provider and is typically made transparent to Consumers. In addition, Public Cloud providers continually add to their wide range of modern PaaS services like AI, ML, and big data analytics, facilitating digital transformation.
Ecosystem and Vendor Options
Private Cloud: Technologies and solutions supported by the in-house team and infrastructure, which provide flexibility and customization but is limited by the expertise of your team.
Public Cloud: Access to a vast ecosystem of existing services and solutions from various vendors, but limited to the solutions provided by the marketplace.
Delving into the Private Cloud
Self-managed Private clouds are frequently leveraged when there is a high level of internal skills and a desire to manage and maintain on-premises infrastructure. Managed private clouds can be beneficial when taking advantage of MSP services provided by existing colocation partners hosting legacy systems. This can be particularly useful when organizations have modern applications with latency-sensitive integrations with legacy systems. The challenges may include higher initial (CapEx) investment and the need to maintain in-house expertise for support and management.
Unfurling the Public Cloud Landscape
Public clouds stand out for their scalability and broad capabilities offered through PaaS services. They can be particularly beneficial for startups and smaller organizations due to lower upfront costs and the pay-as-you-consume cost model; They can also be an advantage for large enterprises that require vast resource pools and seasonal workloads that need access to high resources for only certain periods of the year. Challenges include risk of runaway costs without the proper governance controls to monitor and manage resource consumption.
Questions? Ask Cavan
Start Your ConversationKey Decision Points in the Private vs. Public Cloud Debate
- Security Needs: Assess whether the organization requires the heightened control of physical security of a private cloud or can operate within the shared resource model of a public cloud. Public clouds are continually adding enhanced security tools and PaaS offerings that can be leveraged in hybrid-cloud situations as well.
- Budgetary Constraints: Evaluate whether the organization is better suited to handle the Capital investment costs associated with a private cloud or prefers the operational expense of the pay-as-you-go model of a public cloud.
- Scalability and Flexibility: Consider if the business requires the vast scalability of the hyper-scale public cloud or can work within the confines of a private cloud’s capabilities.
- Control and Customization: Determine the necessity for bespoke configurations and control over the computing hardware environment.
Real-World Examples
- Private Cloud Scenario: A financial institution hosts a legacy AS/400 system in a Colocation facility operated by a Managed Service Provider that offers managed virtual private cloud services in the same colocation facility. They want to build a modern, microservices-based front-end application for customer interaction but requires making transactional calls to the backend AS/400 system. Leveraging the MSP’s VPC offering, the organization can leverage modern cloud capabilities while minimizing latency impacts transacting with the legacy system.
- Public Cloud Scenario: A tech startup, typically characterized by rapid growth and variable demands, might find the public cloud more suitable with a low level of capital dollars to spend on hardware infrastructure. The public cloud offers scalability and cost-effectiveness (when monitored and closely managed), allowing the startup to expand its computing resources easily and affordably as its business grows. This flexibility and the elimination of upfront infrastructure investments make the public cloud an attractive option for emerging businesses seeking agility and operational efficiency.
Hybrid Cloud: Best of Both Worlds?
The hybrid cloud model represents a synergistic blend of private and public cloud features, catering to enterprises that rely on legacy, on-premises environments and are transitioning to scalable, agile, and flexible solutions. It is a natural fit for most organizations that are in the process of modernizing older, unsupported applications. This model is ideal for organizations seeking to balance investment between core operations and scalable tasks, enhance performance, and ensure business continuity. However, it does come with challenges such as management complexity and the need for maintaining consistent security capabilities across both environments. In essence, the hybrid cloud offers a customizable, integrated solution that aligns with diverse operational needs, making it a strategic choice for businesses aiming for agility and security.
Making the Choice: Questions to Ask Yourself
When choosing between a private and public cloud, several critical questions can guide your decision. Understanding your organization's specific needs, from security to financial capabilities, scalability requirements, and the need for control and customization, is essential. In the end, it may not be an either/or choice as there may be some applications better suited to a private cloud architecture and other applications that lend themselves well for Public Cloud, resulting in a hybrid architecture.
1. Assess Your Organization's Specific Security Requirements
Data Sensitivity: How sensitive is the data you are handling? Are there stringent regulatory and compliance requirements?
Risk Management: What level of risk is acceptable for your organization? How does each cloud model align with your cybersecurity strategy?
Security Infrastructure: Do you have the necessary infrastructure to secure a private cloud, or would you benefit from the advanced security measures of a public cloud provider?
2. Evaluate Your Long-term Financial Strategy for Cloud Investments
Budget Allocation: What budget can you allocate for cloud services? How does this fit into your overall IT spending? What is the organization’s financial perspective on Capital versus Operational Expenditures?
Cost-Benefit Analysis: Compare the total cost of ownership (TCO) between private and public clouds. This includes not only initial investments but also ongoing operational costs.
Return on Investment: What kind of return can you expect from your cloud investment? How does each option support your business objectives and financial health in the long run?
3. Consider Your Anticipated Growth and Scalability Needs
Business Growth: How rapidly is your business growing, and what are the projections for the future? Does your cloud choice align with this growth?
Scalability/Flexibility: Do you need the ability to scale resources up or down quickly? Can the cloud model you choose accommodate sudden changes in demand? How quickly are new capabilities made available in the chosen cloud platform?
Market Adaptability: How quickly do you need to adapt to market changes or new opportunities? Can your chosen cloud model keep pace with these requirements?
4. Reflect on the Degree of Control and Customization Your Business Processes Require
Operational Control: How much control do you need over your IT environment? Do you require the ability to make immediate changes to your infrastructure?
Customization Needs: Are there specific customizations or configurations your business processes require that may not be feasible in a public cloud environment?
Integration with Existing Systems: How will your chosen cloud model integrate with existing systems and infrastructure? Does it allow for seamless integration, or will it require significant adjustments?
